In today's ETL environment there are two different approach that vendors have given to the ETL community. There are engine-based and code-generator solutions. Each has its advantages and drawbacks as you have stated.
I actaully find it interesting that you state that Oracle Warehouse Builder is a code-generator type of ETL product. I personally see OWB as a engine-based product, since it uses the Oracle database as its engine. A true code-generator type of ETL product differs in that it produces type programs that need to be compiled and are not in a proprietary language. Generally code-generaters will produce ETL programs in languages like COBOL or C. It generally creates very generic program that requires significant work to make efficient. In the case of engine-based products here we have a generally proprietary solution. These products each have their unique data engines that are tuned for performance. They also have a language that allows you to extend the functionality of the product.
So what is the bottom line in this case? You have to choose a product that works for your individual environment and organization. Engine-based products can provide solid performance. Code-generators also provide solid performance, but you will have to have to do more customization with the programs. If your organization does not have enough expertise in these 3rd-Gl languages you may want to choose an engine-based product, which usually have a shorter learning curve.
For More Information
- What do you think about this answer? E-mail us at editor@searchDatabase.com with your feedback.
- The Best Data Warehousing and Business Intelligence Web Links: tips, tutorials, scripts, and more.
- Have an DW tip to offer your fellow administrators and developers? The best tips submitted will receive a cool prize. Submit your tip today!
- Ask your technical data warehousing questions -- or help out your peers by answering them -- in our live discussion forums.
- Ask the Experts yourself: Our SQL, database design, Oracle, SQL Server, DB2, metadata, object-oriented and data warehousing gurus are waiting to answer your toughest questions.
Dig Deeper on Oracle business intelligence and analytics
Related Q&A from Ian Abramson
We are working on the development of a datamart (in 9i) which takes data from two source systems. Since this is a transaction system, there is a lot ... Continue Reading
I am new to Oracle's ETL tool and I need information on data migration using Oracle ETL. Continue Reading
How can PL/SQL be best used for the ETL process? Continue Reading