Q
Problem solve Get help with specific problems with your technologies, process and projects.

# Customers who bought X at least once and Y at least twice

I have a table CUSTOMERS (customer_id) and a table PURCHASES (customer_id, purchase_date, product_id). I am trying...

to find the distinct customers that have bought at least once product_id=X and, in the 12 previous months, bought at least twice product_id=Y. Any idea that could do the job in a minimum time?

Solutions that do the job "in a minimum time" are always challenging. Success depends on the existence of proper indexes. Assuming these are in place, we can still sometimes see markedly different results for solutions written with different query constructions.

The first step towards a solution, the most important step, is to make sure we understand the exact requirements. In this case, we don't care about purchase data, just that it exists. We aren't actually retrieving anything from the PURCHASES table! If you had said "give the date of the latest Product X purchase, and the total number of Product Y purchases" then we'd need to write a totally different query.

Here's one solution:

```select customer_id
from CUSTOMERS as C
where exists
( select *
from PURCHASES
where customer_id
= C.customer_id
and product_id = 'X' )

and 2 <=
( select count(*)
from PURCHASES
where customer_id
= C.customer_id
and product_id = 'Y'
and purchase_date
between date1
and date2 )```

Each of the two subqueries above is a correlated subquery. This means that it considers only those purchases which match the customer_id of the correlated row in the main query.

One advantage of using correlated subqueries is that it's fairly easy to understand what they're doing. They "read" well. In this case, though, there are two of them, which leaves open the possibility that the database optimizer will generate two separate joins in order to execute them. (Correlated subqueries are usually executed as joins.)

Here's a different solution:

```select C.customer_id
from CUSTOMERS as C
inner
join PURCHASES as P
on C.customer_id
= P.customer_id
group
by C.customer_id
having 0 <
sum(
case when P.product_id = 'X'
then 1 else 0 end
)
and 2 <=
sum(
case when P.product_id = 'Y'
and P.purchase_date
between date1
and date2
then 1 else 0 end
)```

Here you can see we've taken matters into our own hands and performed one join explicitly. Note that we're still just selecting from the CUSTOMERS table. The WHERE EXISTS construction is replaced by taking a count and making sure it's not zero. The counts are achieved by obtaining the SUM of a column of 1's and 0's.

Which of the solutions is faster? Try them both, and see.

This was last published in March 2005

#### Have a question for an expert?

Get answers from a TechTarget expert on whatever's puzzling you.

You will be able to add details on the next page.

#### Start the conversation

Send me notifications when other members comment.

## SearchDataManagement

• ### Focus, scope and spotting opportunity are key to role of CDO

Chief data officers and experts see the CDO role as changing to a more strategic orientation -- especially finding key ...

• ### Good data quality for machine learning is an analytics must

As companies add machine learning applications, they need to really understand -- and be able to improve -- their data. That's ...

• ### Chief data officer role: Searching for consensus

The chief data officer role is about many things -- regulations, innovation, AI and more. Consultant Randy Bean discussed the ...

• ### Data analytics in government efforts lack structure

Data analytics in government agencies lack organization, focusing on immediate problems instead of attacking underlying causes ...

• ### A complete guide to buying data discovery software

Data discovery software turns data into business insights, and it's vital for GDPR compliance. This guide outlines the products ...

• ### Rising demand for business analytics education programs

Colleges and universities are increasingly offering business analytics degrees. The graduates can help build IT and business ...

## SearchSAP

• ### On-premises, hosted most popular S/4HANA deployment options

The pure cloud -- SaaS -- version of SAP's newest ERP, S/4HANA Cloud, lacks some of the same features of the on-premises version....

• ### S/4HANA public cloud version can get lost in cloud confusion

The 'true' public cloud is the streamlined SaaS version of on-premises S/4. But private cloud options are often conflated with ...

• ### SAP S/4HANA migration: What you need to know

There's a lot to consider when contemplating a move to SAP S/4HANA, and this essential guide provides a starting point, including...

## SearchSQLServer

• ### Six sample databases for SQL Server and how to find them

SQL Server sample databases are useful for test and dev, but they can be difficult to parse. Use this SQL database sample ...

• ### A quick tutorial on SQL Server maintenance plans

SQL Server maintenance plans get a bad rap, but for DBAs who need a simple way to maintain databases, Microsoft's built-in tools ...

• ### Proposed Microsoft-GitHub buy confirms open source role in cloud

The looming Microsoft-GitHub pairing confirms the company's rebirth as an open source friend. Data tools on the Azure cloud are ...

## TheServerSide.com

• ### Jenkins Git integration: GitHub pull request via the Git plugin

This Jenkins Git integration tutorial demonstrates how to create a freestyle build job that performs a Jenkins GitHub pull ...

• ### Financial firms, vendors push self-service software delivery

Self-service DevOps automation appeals to enterprises that must push out new code as they adapt to changing requirements.

• ### IT projects and software teams need to include Agile people

Not every idea deserves equal weight in a software development project, but Agile people know that garnering input from a wide ...

## SearchDataCenter

• ### Four top open source SIEM tools you should know

Open source SIEM software offers organizations a way to test capabilities and augment existing functionalities for analytics and ...

• ### Rackspace colocation program hosts users' legacy servers

Rackspace now has a managed colocation program that it hopes to upsell its customers with additional services, once their servers...

Broadcom has acquired CA Technologies in a move some believe is largely financially motivated, while others see an opportunity ...

## SearchContentManagement

• ### At OpenText Enterprise World, security and AI take center stage

OpenText unveiled its new application, OT2, at OpenText Enterprise World 2018, while also touting the importance of security. ...

• ### Augmented reality devices speed van repairs at Volkswagen U.K.

Augmented reality headsets for garage mechanics speed collaboration between repair shops and experts in the home office to solve ...

• ### Endpoint security tool fueled OpenText's Guidance Software acquisition

Endpoint security was the primary draw for OpenText's Guidance Software acquisition. But plans to improve e-discovery and data ...

## SearchHRSoftware

• ### Cost, doubt about tech hold back AI for HR investment

AI technology will improve the productivity of HR departments by eliminating many routine and transactional processes. But what ...

• ### Health and wellness benefits are exploding; are you keeping up?

A WorldatWork survey shows companies offered a wide variety of health and wellness benefits at an expanded rate last year. Is ...

• ### Automated recruiting solves Groupon's sourcing talent woes

Building a talent pool through effective sourcing is a major effort by Groupon. It is using a recruiting automation tool to find ...

Close