Q
Problem solve Get help with specific problems with your technologies, process and projects.

# Unique indexes and NULLs

I read the answer from Rudy Limeback on unique index and null values (June 05, 2002). He said: "As to your question...

about whether a UNIQUE column can have more than one NULL, I'm certain the answer is No. NULLs are not just another value, they do have a special interpretation, but if the column is UNIQUE (and assuming it allows NULLs), only one row can have a NULL value."

Theoretically I agree with Mister Limeback. However, I was able to create a table in Oracle 7.3 with a unique index in a column with multiple null values.

Later I read the response of Brian Peasland about the difference between PK and unique index constraints (April 16, 2002). He said: "You could use just a UNIQUE index, but that allows NULL values. And you can have multiple rows with NULL values. Therefore, you can't uniquely identify those rows. That's why just a UNIQUE index does not satisfy a PK constraint". His answer is in accordance with my practical results. You can say that a null is not necessarily equal to another null but could be. Null is UNKNOWN.

How is this ambiguity resolved in a unique index column?

The proof is in the pudding, as the saying goes. So lets see a quick example:

```ORA9I SQL> create table test (
2  id number,
3  name varchar2(30));

Table created.

ORA9I SQL> create unique index test_id_idx on
test(id);
Index created.

ORA9I SQL> insert into test values (1,'bob');
1 row created.

ORA9I SQL> insert into test values (NULL,'sue');
1 row created.

ORA9I SQL> insert into test values (NULL,'jane');
1 row created.

ORA9I SQL> commit;
Commit complete.
```
```ORA9I SQL> analyze index test_id_idx validate
structure;
Index analyzed.

ORA9I SQL> select lf_rows,distinct_keys
2  from index_stats;

LF_ROWS DISTINCT_KEYS
---------- -------------
1             1
```

"How is this ambiguity resolved in a unique index column?" It is not resolved since there is no ambiguity. A NULL value will not be stored in the index. So there is no ambiguity.

Keep in mind that my above example is only for one column that is indexed. A composite index, made of more than one column is treated differently. It is the combination of the columns that make a difference. Let's revisit our example and see how it works:

```ORA9I SQL> create unique index test_idx on
test(id,name);
Index created.

ORA9I SQL> insert into test values (1,'bob');
1 row created.

ORA9I SQL> insert into test values (NULL,'sue');
1 row created.

ORA9I SQL> insert into test values (2,NULL);
1 row created.

ORA9I SQL> commit;
Commit complete.

ORA9I SQL> analyze index test_idx validate structure;
Index analyzed.

ORA9I SQL> select lf_rows,distinct_keys from
index_stats;

LF_ROWS DISTINCT_KEYS
---------- -------------
3             3
```
```ORA9I SQL> insert into test values (NULL,NULL);
1 row created.

ORA9I SQL> insert into test values (NULL,NULL);
1 row created.

ORA9I SQL> commit;
Commit complete.

ORA9I SQL> analyze index test_idx validate structure;
Index analyzed.

ORA9I SQL> select lf_rows,distinct_keys from
index_stats;

LF_ROWS DISTINCT_KEYS
---------- -------------
3             3
```

Here, we can clearly see that I've created a table and declared a UNIQUE index on the ID column of that table. You can clearly see that I was able to insert more than one NULL value into that column without raising any errors. Furthermore, let's examine the structure of the index: We can clearly see that the index only has one key value in it. NULL values are not stored in the index. This is why searching for columns that contain a NULL value will not use any index on that column. They are simply not stored in the index. Here, you can see that I created a table and my UNIQUE index is on two columns. I've inserted three rows into the table, two of which have at least one column NULL. As you can see, the index stores all three rows! Notice that if I insert all NULLS into the table's row, then they are not stored in the index: I hope that clears things up!
This was last published in August 2002

## Content

Find more PRO+ content and other member only offers, here.

#### Have a question for an expert?

Get answers from a TechTarget expert on whatever's puzzling you.

You will be able to add details on the next page.

#### Start the conversation

Send me notifications when other members comment.

## SearchDataManagement

• ### How AI and IoT will influence data management in 2018

AI and IoT will alter the data management landscape in 2018, according to analyst James Kobielus. AI will need regular updates, ...

• ### Apache Hadoop 3.0 goes GA, adds hooks for cloud and GPUs

Is this the post-Hadoop era? Not in the eyes of Hadoop 3.0 backers, who see the latest update to the big data framework ...

• ### Expert: For BI, you must know the data integration process

Understanding the data integration process is central to self-service BI and data architecture design, consultant Rick Sherman ...

• ### Infographic: The evolution of the chief data officer role

The CDO role, which has never been rigidly defined, is undergoing a face-lift as emerging technologies present new opportunities ...

• ### Predictive analytics projects can bolster business decisions

Blind faith in predictive models can result in flawed business decisions. Analytics teams need to manage predictive processes ...

• ### How predictive analytics techniques and processes work

Predictive analytics is no longer confined to data scientists and other highly skilled analysts. But other users need to ...

## SearchSAP

• ### SAP S/4HANA Cloud and indirect access will dominate 2018

Industry experts say SAP S/4HANA Cloud migrations, Leonardo and Cloud Platform are the technology issues for SAP in 2018; on the ...

When a Dutch energy grid provider needed to develop new business apps on top of SAP ERP, it turned to the Mendix RAD platform to ...

• ### SAP's Timo Elliott on enterprise chatbot AI technology

The SAP global innovation evangelist expects AI to affect businesses in three ways: human-computer interaction, automation of ...

## SearchSQLServer

• ### Meltdown and Spectre fixes eyed for SQL Server performance issues

Microsoft has responded to the Spectre and Meltdown chip vulnerabilities with patches and other fixes. But IT teams need to sort ...

• ### Five SQL Server maintenance steps you should take -- ASAP

Putting off SQL Server administration tasks can lead to database problems. Enact these often-neglected maintenance items to help ...

• ### Microsoft Cosmos DB takes Azure databases to a higher level

Azure Cosmos DB brings a new element to the database lineup of Microsoft's cloud platform, offering multiple data models and a ...

## TheServerSide.com

• ### Spring creator Rod Johnson releases API for implementing DevOps

Find out about Rod Johnson's latest project, which promises to simplify the process of implementing DevOps and streamlining the ...

• ### What Java developers need to know about TypeScript syntax

For Java developers transitioning into JavaScript frameworks, like React and Angular, this TypeScript tutorial on syntax will ...

• ### AWS Cloud9 IDE threatens Microsoft developer base

With its Cloud9 IDE, AWS challenges Microsoft where it matters most -- with the developer community, where Microsoft has ...

## SearchDataCenter

• ### Three requirements for a hybrid cloud computing deployment

As the hybrid cloud computing approach gains steam, organizations will need to pay close attention to cross-cloud connectivity ...

• ### Five debunked myths about SSD issues

Solid-state drives are mature now, and the technology has eclipsed hard disk drives with superior performance, manageability and ...

• ### Future data center trends hinge on the edge, cloud and staffing

Edge computing, colocation, cloud and IT staffing issues lead the way as industry analysts make their predictions for the future ...

## SearchContentManagement

• ### Agile content management leads to iterative value

An Agile approach to enterprise content management enables companies to continually improve ECM systems and add value steadily ...

• ### Intelligent information management the next wave for ECM

In a 2018 upgrade, M-Files allows users to search for content in multiple repositories, while also being able to automatically ...

• ### SharePoint integration and implementation best practices

Here are some expert advice and tips, as well common definitions, to help make your SharePoint integration and implementation a ...

## SearchFinancialApplications

• ### Finance IT case study: Reporting secrets of Derek Rose

CEO Sacha Rose says specialist reporting tools have saved the company thousands by avoiding unnecessary mistakes.

• ### WestJet turns to gamification to help its Oracle ERP users soar

WestJet's initial gamification project focuses on expense reporting.

• ### The Transformation of HR is Underway

HR is being transformed while we watch.

Close