Q
Problem solve Get help with specific problems with your technologies, process and projects.

# NULL OR TRUE evaluates as TRUE

I have two tables, Customer and Activity, and related fields are CustNum. The Activity table holds all information...

related to services performed. The Code field in Activity holds a number related to a type of service performed. I want to count all of the services for a particular customer prior to the first occurrence of a code (23) which is a lockout. I need to find out how many services were performed before the lockout occurred.

From your description, the Activity table must have some column which determines the sequence that services were performed in. Otherwise, you would never know which services were performed before the row with Code 23. So let's call this column ServiceDate. We want to count Activity rows that have a ServiceDate that is earlier than the ServiceDate of the row with Code 23.

This sample data illustrates the situations we need to cover:

```CustNum   ServiceDate   Code

6      2003-02-28     15
6      2003-03-15     78
6      2003-03-30     23
6      2003-04-29     01

7      2003-03-31     23

8      2003-01-05     21
8      2003-01-31     23
8      2003-02-01     66
8      2003-02-02     23

9      2003-01-15     44
9      2003-02-22     55```

For CustNum 6, there are two rows with a ServiceDate earlier than the ServiceDate of the row with Code 23. For Custnum 7, there is none. For CustNum 8, though, there is one row before the first Code 23, and another (or three, depending on how you look at it) before the second; this illustrates the importance of considering sample data to uncover hidden "whoopsies" in logic. If we simply count the rows before a Code 23 we will get two answers for CustNum 8. So let's agree we want only the number of rows before the first Code 23.

For CustNum 9, there is no row with Code 23, so any expression involving its date would be NULL. This is another "whoopsie" and means we need to refine the requirement once again. We want the number of rows before the first Code 23, but if there is no Code 23, then we want all rows. Whew!

```select CustNum, count(*) as services
from Activity  A
where ServiceDate <
( select min(ServiceDate)
from Activity
where CustNum = A.CustNum
and Code = 23 )
or not exists
( select 1
from Activity
where CustNum = A.CustNum
and Code = 23 )
group by CustNum```

Both subqueries are correlated, and will examine only those rows related (via the correlation variable A) to each outer row. The first subquery has an aggregate function but requires no GROUP BY because all rows in each group have the same CustNum.

If there is a Code 23 in the group, the first subquery returns a date, which is compared to ServiceDate, yielding either TRUE or FALSE for every row. The NOT EXISTS condition evaluates FALSE but this does not come into play, because no matter what the date comparison evaluates as, that evaluation is unchanged by combining it with OR FALSE.

If there is no Code 23 in the group, the first subquery returns NULL, and the ServiceDate comparison is therefore NULL. However, the NOT EXISTS is TRUE. In SQL, NULL OR TRUE evaluates as TRUE, so all rows in the group are selected if there is no Code 23.

Note that the two subqueries are not quite identical. You could replace the literal 1 with MIN(ServiceDate), and the NOT EXISTS subquery would work exactly the same way, except then the subqueries would be identical, a subtle hint to the optimizer not to actually run two subqueries. You might also try combining the two OR conditions into one, using COALESCE, although my preference is for two conditions because, to me, they convey the business rule more clearly when stated separately.

This was last published in April 2003

## Content

Find more PRO+ content and other member only offers, here.

#### Have a question for an expert?

Get answers from a TechTarget expert on whatever's puzzling you.

You will be able to add details on the next page.

#### Start the conversation

Send me notifications when other members comment.

## SearchDataManagement

• ### Blockchain data disruption aborning, IDC analyst says

Blockchain data technology disruption may be in the offing. IDC's Stewart Bond says architecture at the core of controversial ...

• ### Potent NoSQL architecture engaged for building new applications

Behind hyperbolic terms like 'digital transformation' are innovative systems of engagement. DataStax CEO Billy Bosworth joins ...

• ### Finance data governance program gets new start, broader focus

Businesses constantly need to evolve their programs for governing data. Nationwide's finance data governance team shares how it ...

• ### Cognitive computing technologies still deliver mixed results

Cognitive computing tools have come a long way in the last couple of years, but the notion of true cognitive businesses, built ...

• ### Deloitte report reveals the power of unstructured data analytics

The analysis of unstructured data and other so-called dark data types can deliver significant business value, according to a new ...

• ### Ease of use is top priority in selecting self-service analytics tools

A lot of factors go into a choosing a strong, modern BI tool. But several users say ease of use trumped all other considerations ...

## SearchSAP

• ### Future of Ariba Network on display at SAP Ariba Live

SAP Ariba Live shows enhancements to procurement software and looks at the future of the SAP Ariba Network, including machine ...

SAP Vora has been updated to include features that make it easier to deploy and use to get insights from Hadoop big data; SAP IBP...

• ### Chatbots provide faster self-service on SAP systems

The SAP SuccessFactors partnership with collaboration software vendor Slack is just one of many efforts to make little robotic ...

## SearchSQLServer

• ### Redgate tools help bring database DevOps to Visual Studio 2017

So far, data has been left out of the DevOps discussion. But DevOps for databases could grow if tools like Redgate's bundle ...

• ### Conquer real-time operational analytics in SQL Server 2016

Analytics helps improve business operations, and SQL Server 2016 users can master it -- in real time, using operational data in a...

• ### SQL Server machine learning goes full throttle on operational data

Artificial intelligence is a hot topic in IT, and Microsoft has made strides to synchronize SQL Server with machine learning ...

## TheServerSide

• ### Does reading XML while writing JSON make me a bad person?

I'm always writing JSON code, loving its flexibility and forgiveness. But when I call an external service, I want to be reading ...

• ### Stop adding web UI frameworks like JSR-371 to the Java EE spec

Java EE's Servlet and JSP API provide a fine foundation for handling a web-based request-response cycle. Adding UI frameworks ...

• ### Declarative Jenkins pipeline the latest new feature in DevOps tooling

Looking to get more out of your DevOps tooling? The declarative Jenkins pipeline helps take continuous integration and continuous...

## SearchDataCenter

• ### IoT certifications land on data center admins' to-do list

IoT is still an emerging field, but data center admins should at least consider certification options to make their resume stand ...

• ### Manage and optimize IBM z Systems software costs

Some mainframe users find it tough to navigate IBM's sub-capacity pricing model. Consider tools like SCRT to more efficiently ...

• ### Find the right data center cooling systems for hyper-converged

Hyper-converged infrastructure can cause new data center cooling challenges. Before implementation, determine which temperatures ...

## SearchContentManagement

• ### Seven features to consider when picking enterprise collaboration tools

As collaboration needs grow, more options are beginning to sprout up. Here are the features to think about when selecting the ...

• ### Microsoft Teams joins growing business chat software market

The general release of Microsoft's latest product puts Slack square in its scope, with hopes of taking a chunk from the business ...

Headless CMS can be a difficult pivot for dyed-in-the-wool legacy shops, but remixing content in this new model with RESTful APIs...

## SearchFinancialApplications

• ### Report rates e-sourcing, spend analysis and contract management tools

Gartner Magic Quadrant finds plenty of room for growth in market for cloud-based strategic sourcing application suites that can ...

• ### Benefits administration systems that use analytics liked by employers

HR tech systems are increasingly using analytics in benefits administration, including using claims data; meanwhile, APIs are ...

• ### Degreed integrates and organizes content from online learning software

Atlassian and Intel use cloud-based Degreed to integrate e-books, articles, videos and other content and recommend training for ...

Close