Q
Problem solve Get help with specific problems with your technologies, process and projects.

# Many-to-many links that aren't there

I have People linked to Roles with three tables: People, Links, Roles. People has PersonName and PersonID columns,...

Roles has RoleID, and RoleName columns, and Links has PersonID and RoleID columns. Each person can have zero or more roles, each role can have zero or more people. How do I select (distinct) all names that are NOT linked to a specified role?

I'm not totally sure whether you want to list people that are not linked to one specific role, or people that are not linked to any role at all. So let's answer both questions. Here's some sample data:

```People
PersonID  PersonName
24      Homer
26      Marge
31      Bart
33      Lisa
36      Maggie
45      Apu

Roles

RoleID  RoleName
101   Technician
103   Homemaker
107   Student
111   Teacher

PersonID  RoleID
24       101
26       103
31       107
33       107```

Let's try to find people without a specific role, say Student. If we already know the RoleID, 107, then the query is:

```select PersonName
from People
left outer

This query works by specifying the RoleID condition in the join, and then testing for no match. To see why this works, let's ignore the WHERE clause for a moment, and look at the rows produced by the left outer join. Remember, the only possible joins are to Links rows with Roleid 107:

```People    People      Links     Links
PersonID  PersonName  PersonID  RoleID
24      Homer       null      null
26      Marge       null      null
31      Bart        31        107
33      Lisa        33        107
36      Maggie      null      null```

The WHERE clause can now be applied, to select those people without a match to a RoleID 107 Links row. Homer, Marge, and Maggie are not Students.

The correct results are not produced if the Links.Roleid = 107 condition is moved from the ON clause to the WHERE clause. You can try this on your own if you wish.

Now, if the specific RoleID is not known, but the RoleName is, then just simply extend the left outer join to the third table:

```select PersonName
from People
left outer
left outer
join Roles
and                Roles.RoleName = 'Student'
where Roles.RoleID is null```

Again, the technique here is to specify the restricting condition in an ON clause, rather than in the WHERE clause.

Finally, if you want people with no role at all, then use the first left outer join query, joining only People and Links, without any Roleid condition in the ON clause, again selecting unmatched rows in the WHERE clause. This will give you Apu.

By the way, you may have assumed from the title of this answer, Many-to-many links that aren't there, that the solution might involve a NOT EXISTS subquery. Yes, it's possible to do it that way:

```select PersonName
from People
where not exists
( select 1
where PersonID = People.PersonID
and Roleid = 107 )```

However, I prefer the left outer join syntax.

This was last published in October 2002

## Content

Find more PRO+ content and other member only offers, here.

#### Have a question for an expert?

Get answers from a TechTarget expert on whatever's puzzling you.

You will be able to add details on the next page.

#### Start the conversation

Send me notifications when other members comment.

## SearchDataManagement

• ### Connectedness is king, as Neo4j graph database ports to Spark

The Neo4j graph database emphasizes easy relationship mapping for diverse data points. Now, its related Cypher query language is ...

• ### NewSQL databases rise anew -- MemSQL, Spanner among contenders

The NewSQL database was almost hidden when Hadoop and NoSQL arose. Now, as more big data teams move toward production uses, ...

• ### Good data quality for analytics becomes an IT imperative

High-quality data is a must for analytics applications. That's driving more demand for data quality tools, but quality ...

• ### Automating machine learning puts analytical models on autopilot

With data scientists in short supply and the value of machine learning models growing ever more evident, software vendors are ...

• ### Hiring vs. training data scientists: The case for each approach

Hiring data scientists is easier said than done -- so should you try to train current employees in data science skills? That ...

• ### Tableau targets data preparation software with Project Maestro

As Tableau and other high-level applications look to automate more functionality, stand-alone data preparation tools have to ...

## SearchSAP

• ### Responsible sourcing can be good for business

A company's reputation and bottom line can be damaged if its suppliers engage in harmful practices. Responsible sourcing and risk...

• ### SAP TechEd 2017 focuses on next-gen development tools

At SAP TechEd 2017, SAP rolled out some new developer tools that are intended to extend the SAP platform and drive development of...

• ### SAP Analytics Cloud helps paper-maker tell a good business story

SAP Analytics Cloud software is helping paper manufacturer Pratt Industries tell the story of monthly forecasts more accurately, ...

## SearchSQLServer

• ### Microsoft Azure cloud database activity takes off at Connect();

Microsoft Connect(); 2017 saw the addition of MariaDB and Cassandra to the Azure cloud database lineup. Also discussed: A set of ...

• ### Microsoft technology refresh touches SQL Server, integration tooling

Microsoft is at work on a delicate technology refresh affecting database tuning and architecture, as well as data integration and...

• ### Microsoft boosts SQL Server machine learning services

Python and R are among the tools in the SQL Server machine learning toolkit. Native T-SQL scoring is also on the agenda, as ...

## TheServerSide.com

• ### Trying to make DevOps work? Learn how Nike just did it.

Many organizations struggle as they transition to DevOps. But it can be a challenge making DevOps work. Here we look at how Nike ...

• ### Everything to know about overcoming digital transformation challenges

As organizations adopt new technologies, like blockchain, IoT devices and deep learning, strategies must be developed to address ...

• ### How to solve Java and JavaScript performance issues

Given the complexity of client side user interfaces, along with the often limited processing power of many mobile devices, ...

## SearchDataCenter

• ### CA Technologies antes up with AI in mainframe software tools

CA Technologies' debut of mainframe software tools with AI and machine learning extends the platform's relevance in a world ...

• ### Security, vendor choices affect server purchases for IT buyers

Server selection is a quandary for IT, as security, the use of file servers and whether multiple servers of CPU systems will meet...

• ### How to choose a server based on your data center's needs

In an effort to optimize performance in the enterprise, IT should evaluate top priorities to determine how to choose a server and...

## SearchContentManagement

• ### Q&A: New CEO bets on open source future for Acquia CMS

The Acquia CMS took the Red Hat model to content management by commercializing open source Drupal. What's next? We ask co-founder...

• ### CMS analytics arms businesses with a strategic planning edge

Content analytics for CMSes mines business value from free text in data lakes, so it's time to go prospecting for gold with this ...

• ### Enterprise content management systems boost intelligence

Content analytics moves beyond the tried-and-true web analytics style of insights, adding natural language processing and images ...

## SearchFinancialApplications

• ### Finance IT case study: Reporting secrets of Derek Rose

CEO Sacha Rose says specialist reporting tools have saved the company thousands by avoiding unnecessary mistakes.

• ### WestJet turns to gamification to help its Oracle ERP users soar

WestJet's initial gamification project focuses on expense reporting.

• ### The Transformation of HR is Underway

HR is being transformed while we watch.

Close